content

Valuing a Partner’s Share Upon Exit: Which Documents Affect Its Value?

Introduction

When a partner exits a company, determining the value of their share is not simply a mathematical calculation based on their ownership percentage in the company’s capital. The company may have achieved significant growth since its establishment, acquired new assets, or accumulated liabilities and debts that are not clearly reflected in its initial records. As a result, the value expected by the withdrawing partner may differ from the amount considered appropriate by the remaining partners.

This is where documentation becomes particularly important. Documents provide the foundation for assessing the company’s actual financial position and verifying the value of its assets, liabilities, revenues, and commercial rights. Each document may reveal information that affects the final valuation, either positively or negatively.

Missing or inaccurate documents may lead to an unfair valuation, disputes between partners, or the discovery of financial obligations after the exit has been completed. Therefore, it is essential to prepare a comprehensive file before determining the value of the share or negotiating its sale price.

In this article, we review the key documents that affect the valuation of a partner’s share upon exit, how they are used, and the mistakes that should be avoided to ensure a clear settlement that protects the rights of all parties.

First: Why Is Share Capital Alone Not Enough to Value a Partner’s Share?

Some partners may believe that the value of a share upon exit is simply equal to the partner’s ownership percentage of the capital registered in the company’s Articles of Association. However, this assumption does not necessarily reflect the company’s actual economic value.

Share capital indicates the contribution made at incorporation or following any legally registered amendments. However, it does not provide a complete picture of how the company has developed over the years. The company’s value may increase as a result of business expansion, customer growth, and improved profitability. Conversely, it may decrease due to losses, debts, or a decline in the value of its assets.

For example, if a partner contributed SAR 300,000 in exchange for a 30% ownership stake, this does not mean that the value of their share will remain SAR 300,000 when they exit. The company may have expanded and acquired assets, contracts, and a customer base that increase its value. Alternatively, it may have incurred losses and liabilities that reduce its value compared with its position at incorporation.

Therefore, three concepts must be distinguished:

Nominal Value of the Share: The value associated with the partner’s ownership percentage in the company’s registered capital.
Book Value: The value recorded in the company’s accounting records and financial statements in accordance with the applicable accounting policies and standards.
Fair or Economic Value: An estimate of the share’s value based on the company’s assets, liabilities, financial performance, and other relevant factors, using an appropriate valuation basis.

These values do not necessarily have to be equal. The book value may be lower than the economic value due to intangible assets or business growth. Conversely, it may be higher than the actual value if certain assets are recorded at amounts that no longer reflect their current condition.

Second: What Is the Legal Basis for Valuing a Partner’s Share Upon Exit?

The type of company and the nature of the exit must be identified before selecting a valuation method, as the Saudi Companies Law distinguishes between cases involving withdrawal from a company and cases involving the transfer of a share to another party.

One of the important provisions in this context is Article 49 of the Companies Law, which addresses the valuation of a partner’s share in a general partnership or limited partnership upon withdrawal or removal. It provides that, unless the partners agree on the value of the share or the Articles of Association specify a valuation method, its value shall be determined through a report prepared by one or more accredited valuers. The report must establish the fair value of each partner’s share in the company’s assets as of the date on which the withdrawal or removal takes place.

The article also addresses the transfer of a share and provides that, unless the Articles of Association specify another method, the share shall be valued according to the amount agreed upon with the transferee.

For a limited liability company, the rules governing the transfer of shares to third parties and the other partners’ rights to redeem the share must also be considered, in accordance with Article 178 of the Law, in addition to any relevant provisions in the Articles of Association.

This means that valuation should not begin with selecting a figure that one party considers appropriate. Instead, the correct legal procedure must first be identified, followed by a review of the agreements and documents that help establish a defensible and properly documented value.

Third: Financial Statements Are Among the Most Important Documents Affecting Share Value

Financial statements are among the primary documents required by a valuer when examining a company, as they provide an organized overview of its operating results, financial position, and cash flows.

It is not advisable to rely on the financial statements for only one year. Instead, available statements covering several years should be provided so the valuer can understand the company’s performance trends and determine whether it has achieved stable growth or experienced significant fluctuations.

1. Statement of Financial Position

The statement of financial position presents the company’s assets, liabilities, and equity at a specific date. It helps identify what the company owns and what it owes.

Key items include:

Cash and bank balances.
Accounts receivable and amounts due from customers.
Inventory and merchandise.
Real estate, equipment, and fixed assets.
Investments and other assets.
Loans and banking facilities.
Accounts payable to suppliers.
Current and long-term liabilities.
Partners’ equity and retained earnings.

These figures affect the valuation by helping determine net assets. However, it is necessary to verify whether the assets can actually be collected or sold and whether the recorded liabilities are accurate.

For example, a large balance in accounts receivable does not necessarily mean that the company has an equivalent amount of fully collectible funds. These accounts may include overdue invoices, disputed debts, or amounts that are difficult to recover.

2. Income Statement

The income statement presents the company’s revenues and expenses, as well as its final operating results over a specific period, indicating whether the company has generated profits or incurred losses.

The valuer typically reviews the following items:

Total sales and revenues.
Cost of sales or service delivery.
Operating and administrative expenses.
Salaries and wages.
Financing expenses.
Operating profit.
Net profit or loss.

The purpose of reviewing the income statement is not limited to determining whether the company is profitable. Its analysis also helps identify the sources of profit and assess whether those profits are sustainable.

A company may report high profits in a particular year because of an asset sale or an exceptional source of income, without this necessarily indicating that its core business can generate similar results in the future.

3. Cash Flow Statement

A company may report accounting profits while struggling to generate sufficient liquidity to meet its obligations. Therefore, financial performance cannot be assessed based on profits alone.

The cash flow statement shows the movement of money into and out of the company through operating, investing, and financing activities.

This statement helps answer important questions, such as:

Does the core business generate cash consistently?
Does the company rely on borrowing to cover its expenses?
Does it invest significant amounts in expansion?
Does it experience delays in collecting receivables?
Does it face cash flow pressure despite reporting accounting profits?

The answers to these questions may influence the selection of the valuation method and the assumptions used to estimate the company’s future value.

Fourth: Accounting Documents That Reveal the True Position of Assets and Liabilities

Although financial statements are important, they may not be sufficient in every case. The valuer may need detailed supporting documents to verify recorded figures and ensure that the information reflects the company’s actual position.

1. Trial Balance and General Ledger

The trial balance is used to review account balances, while the general ledger provides details of the transactions recorded in each account during a specific period.

These documents help verify financial accounts, identify unusual entries, and understand the nature of amounts recorded as payable by or receivable by the company.

For example, the statement of financial position may show a large amount owed to one of the partners. However, the general ledger may reveal whether this balance represents an actual loan, expenses paid by the partner on behalf of the company, or transactions that require reconciliation.

2. Bank Statements

Bank statements are an important means of verifying cash balances and actual financial transactions.

The valuer may need to review the relevant statements and reconcile them with the accounting records, paying attention to large transfers, unusual transactions, restricted balances, and existing banking facilities.

The balance shown in a bank statement should not automatically be considered fully available to the company without reviewing any restrictions or obligations associated with it.

3. Accounts Receivable and Payable Aging Reports

Aging reports show the amounts owed to the company and the amounts it must pay, classified according to how long they have been outstanding.

These reports help identify:

Customers with overdue payments.
Debts that have passed their due dates.
Disputed amounts.
Suppliers whose payments remain outstanding.
Obligations approaching their due dates.

Doubtful debts may reduce the expected value of assets, while unrecorded or overdue liabilities may reveal financial risks that affect the company’s value.

4. Inventory Records and Stocktaking Reports

If the company operates in the commercial or industrial sector, inventory may represent a significant portion of its assets.

Therefore, physical stocktaking reports, item and quantity records, cost records, and reports on obsolete, damaged, or slow-moving inventory should be provided.

Inventory should not be valued solely according to its recorded cost if some goods have lost their value or can no longer be sold at the expected price.

5. Fixed Asset Register

The fixed asset register includes real estate, equipment, machinery, vehicles, devices, and other property used in the business.

It should include details of each asset, its purchase date, original cost, accumulated depreciation, location, and condition, along with documents proving ownership or the right to use it.

The valuer may need to inspect certain assets or consult a specialized expert to determine their current value, particularly when they represent a significant proportion of the company’s total value.

Fifth: Contracts and Agreements That May Increase or Decrease Share Value

A company’s value does not depend solely on its assets and profits. It may have long-term contracts or commercial agreements that secure future revenues. At the same time, it may be subject to substantial contractual obligations, penalties, or performance-related risks.

Therefore, all active contracts and agreements should be reviewed rather than relying exclusively on the financial figures presented in the statements.

1. Customer Contracts

Customer contracts help determine the stability of revenues, the nature of commercial relationships, the remaining contract period, and the terms governing renewal or termination.

Long-term contracts may represent significant value if they secure predictable future cash flows. However, it is important to verify whether they can continue following a change in the ownership structure.

Some contracts may include a clause requiring the other party’s approval in the event of a change of control or transfer of shares. Ignoring such a clause may create risks that affect the valuation.

2. Supplier and Supply Agreements

These agreements reveal the company’s obligations toward suppliers, purchase prices, payment terms, minimum order quantities, and penalties for non-compliance.

Favorable supply agreements may help the company reduce costs and improve profit margins. However, they may also include purchase commitments or penalties that increase financial risks.

3. Lease Agreements

Lease agreements for offices, warehouses, factories, and commercial premises affect future expenses and may create obligations extending over several years.

The review should cover the contract term, rental amount, increase and renewal provisions, termination conditions, security deposits, and any accumulated obligations.

4. Financing and Guarantee Agreements

Financing agreements show the amount of loans and credit facilities, repayment dates, financing rates, and guarantees provided to creditors.

Particular attention should be paid to personal guarantees signed by the withdrawing partner, as leaving the company does not automatically release the partner from those guarantees.

5. Partners’ Agreements and Articles of Association

These documents may contain provisions that directly affect the exit process and the value of the share, such as valuation mechanisms, pre-emption rights, transfer restrictions, and conditions for approving the entry of a new investor.

They should therefore be reviewed before negotiations begin, to ensure that the agreement is not based on assumptions that conflict with the partners’ existing arrangements.

Sixth: Legal and Regulatory Documents That May Affect Valuation

A company may be financially stable but still face legal or regulatory risks that are not clearly reflected in its financial statements. Therefore, the valuer needs to review legal documents that may affect business continuity or create potential liabilities.

1. Commercial Registration, Articles of Association, and Amendments

These documents identify the company’s legal form, capital, partners’ ownership percentages, management powers, and restrictions on share transfers.

The Articles of Association should be compared with the commercial registration and subsequent resolutions to ensure that the registered ownership percentages are accurate and that no amendments have been made without being reflected in the available documents.

Any partners’ agreements should also be reviewed, as they may contain additional rights or obligations that affect the value of the share or the ability to sell it.

2. Licenses and Regulatory Approvals

Certain business activities require licenses or approvals from relevant authorities. An expired license or regulatory violation may affect the company’s ability to continue operating.

Therefore, valid licenses, registration certificates, professional or sector-specific approvals, and any official correspondence relating to their renewal, suspension, or revocation should be provided.

If the company depends on a specific license to conduct its business, any issue affecting that license may represent a material risk that influences its valuation.

3. Existing Litigation, Claims, and Disputes

The company must disclose any ongoing lawsuits, arbitration proceedings, or formal claims in which it is involved, whether as a claimant or a defendant.

Important documents include:

Statements of claim and exchanged legal memoranda.
Issued judgments and decisions.
Settlement and reconciliation agreements.
Compensation claims.
Notices of violations and penalties.
Lawyers’ reports assessing legal risks.

The existence of a lawsuit does not necessarily mean that the company’s value should be reduced by the full amount claimed. The nature of the dispute, its likelihood of success, potential amounts, and operational and financial effects must all be examined.

4. Tax and Zakat Documents

It is important to review tax and Zakat returns, registration certificates, assessments, notices, and claims issued by the relevant authorities, in addition to proof of payment or any outstanding objections.

Liabilities relating to previous periods may not have been fully recorded in the financial statements. There may also be penalties or potential differences that affect the company’s net value.

Therefore, financial due diligence should extend beyond accounting balances to include verification of the company’s Zakat and tax position, according to its business activities and obligations.

5. Employment Contracts and Labor Obligations

A company may have financial obligations toward its employees, including outstanding salaries, end-of-service benefits, accrued leave, and potential compensation.

Important documents in this area include:

Employment contracts.
Payroll records.
Leave records.
End-of-service benefit statements.
Employment settlements.
Existing labor claims or complaints.
Obligations related to social insurance.

Reviewing these documents helps identify current and potential liabilities that may not be adequately reflected in certain summarized reports.

Seventh: Intangible Assets and Intellectual Property Rights

A company’s value is not limited to real estate, equipment, and bank balances. It may also own intangible assets that represent an important part of its economic value.

Examples include trademarks, patents, copyrights, software, databases, technologies developed by the company, and certain commercial relationships and rights that can be valued according to their nature.

What Documents Prove Ownership of These Assets?

Trademark registration certificates.
Patent or industrial design registration documents, where applicable.
Intellectual property assignment agreements.
Agreements licensing the use of trademarks or software.
Software and system development contracts.
Documents proving ownership of domain names.
Confidentiality and information protection agreements.
Documents establishing ownership of content, designs, or digital products.

These documents are important because they help verify that the rights are actually owned by the company rather than by a founder, employee, or external party.

For example, a company may own a well-known trademark. However, if the trademark is registered in another person’s name without a clear agreement governing the company’s right to use it, a legal risk may arise that affects the value of this asset.

Similarly, owning a successful website or application does not automatically prove that the company owns all its components. Development contracts, licenses, and usage rights must also be reviewed.

Eighth: Documents Related to Customers, the Market, and Business Activities

A company’s ability to retain customers and maintain sales affects its valuation, particularly when methods based on profits or future cash flows are used.

For this reason, the valuer may need to review additional documents, such as:

Sales reports by customer, product, and period.
Customer databases and transaction histories.
Subscription and recurring service contracts.
Contract renewal and cancellation rates.
Forecast sales reports and confirmed orders.
Expansion plans and projects currently being implemented.
Competition and market share data, where available.
Branch and sales channel performance reports.

These records help determine whether the company depends on a single customer or a limited number of customers, how stable its revenues are, and whether its growth is likely to continue.

If a significant percentage of the company’s revenue comes from a single customer, the termination of that relationship may cause a substantial decline in revenue. Conversely, a diversified customer base and recurring contracts may strengthen the stability of future cash flows.

It is also important to distinguish between signed contracts and expected sales opportunities. A quotation or preliminary negotiation does not necessarily represent guaranteed revenue that can be valued in the same way as a binding contract.

Ninth: How Does the Valuer Use These Documents to Determine the Company’s Value?

After collecting and verifying the documents, the valuer begins analyzing the information and selecting the valuation method appropriate to the company’s nature, the purpose of the valuation, and the availability of information.

There is no single method suitable for all companies. A method that works well for an industrial business may not be the most appropriate for a technology company or a business that relies on contracts and recurring revenues.

The main valuation methods include:

1. Net Asset Method

This method involves determining the actual value of the company’s assets and subtracting its liabilities.

It is useful when the company’s value depends largely on its property and assets, or when profits are unstable and do not, on their own, reflect the business’s economic value.

This method requires verifying the value of real estate, equipment, inventory, receivables, and liabilities rather than automatically relying on book values.

2. Income and Cash Flow Method

This method is based on estimating the cash flows the company is expected to generate in the future and calculating their present value using a discount rate that reflects the relevant risks and factors.

It requires reliable documents, such as historical financial statements, projected budgets, operating plans, contracts, and revenue and expense data.

The more unrealistic the forecasts or weaker the supporting data, the greater the likelihood that the valuation will differ from the company’s actual future performance.

3. Market Multiples Method

This method compares the company with similar businesses in terms of activity, size, and financial characteristics, using indicators such as earnings multiples, revenue multiples, or other appropriate metrics.

However, the effectiveness of this method depends on selecting suitable comparable companies and taking into account differences in size, risk, growth, profitability, and financial structure.

A direct comparison may not be fair if the company operates in a different market or has a business model that differs significantly from those of the selected comparable companies.

4. Combining More Than One Method

In some cases, using more than one valuation method may be the most appropriate way to reach a balanced estimate, particularly when the company owns significant assets while also generating stable operating profits.

The method should not be selected simply because it produces the highest or lowest value or serves the interests of one party. Instead, the choice must be justified by the company’s nature, the purpose of the valuation, and the available information.

Tenth: How Is the Value of a Partner’s Share Determined After Valuing the Company?

Once the company’s value has been determined using the appropriate valuation approach, the next step is to calculate the partner’s share while reviewing any rights and obligations associated with it.

If the company’s estimated value is SAR 10 million and the partner owns 25%, the preliminary mathematical value of the share would be SAR 2.5 million, before considering any adjustments or specific rights and obligations related to the case.

However, this example does not mean that every share is always worth the same proportion of the company’s total value. Several factors may affect the final result, including:

Any specific agreement between the partners regarding valuation.
Differences in the rights attached to shares or share classes, where applicable.
Amounts owed to or by the partner.
Loans, guarantees, or obligations associated with the partner.
The agreed valuation date.
Rights arising from transactions that took place before the withdrawal date.
The nature of the exit, whether it involves withdrawal or transfer of the share.

No financial deduction or addition should be made automatically without a contractual, accounting, or legal basis to justify it.

Eleventh: Documentation Mistakes That May Lead to an Unfair Valuation

Even when a large number of files are available, the valuation may still be inaccurate if the documents are outdated, incomplete, or do not reflect the actual business situation.

Common mistakes include:

Providing outdated financial statements: The company may have undergone significant changes after the statements were prepared. Therefore, updated information should be provided up to the valuation date.
Concealing liabilities or claims: Failure to disclose lawsuits, debts, or guarantees may result in a valuation that is higher than the company’s actual value.
Failing to reconcile balances with supporting documents: Bank accounts, invoices, contracts, and customer and supplier records should be verified rather than relying on isolated figures.
Mixing company funds with partners’ personal funds: Loans and financial transactions between the company and its partners must be clearly identified and should not be treated as part of the capital without supporting documentation.
Including unconfirmed profits: Expected revenues or opportunities that are not supported by binding contracts should not be treated as guaranteed profits.
Ignoring intellectual property rights: Failure to establish ownership of trademarks, software, or content may result in overlooking assets that significantly affect the company’s value.
Failing to specify the valuation date: The date on which assets, liabilities, and rights are measured must be clearly identified, as changes in the financial position after that date may create disputes over entitlements.
Using a valuation report without examining its basis: The report’s scope, supporting data, assumptions, and limitations should be reviewed rather than relying solely on its final figure.

Twelfth: Checklist of Documents to Prepare Before Valuing a Share

To facilitate the valuation process and reduce the likelihood of disputes, an organized file may be prepared containing the following documents:

Articles of Association and all amendments.
Commercial registration and details of partners and ownership percentages.
Partners’ agreements and any previous exit agreements.
Financial statements for the last three years, where available.
Trial balance and general ledger.
Bank statements and bank reconciliations.
Customer and receivables reports, including aging reports.
Supplier reports and outstanding obligations.
Inventory records and stocktaking reports.
Fixed asset register and ownership documents.
Customer, supplier, lease, and financing contracts.
Loans, credit facilities, guarantees, and sureties.
Licenses and regulatory approvals.
Zakat and tax returns and supporting documents.
Employee files and labor obligations.
Documents relating to lawsuits, claims, and disputes.
Trademark certificates and intellectual property documents.
Projected budgets, business plans, and expected cash flows.

This checklist does not mean that every document is necessarily required in every case. The required documents vary depending on the company’s activity, size, valuation method, and type of exit.

Frequently Asked Questions About Documents Affecting the Valuation of a Partner’s Share

Can a Partner’s Share Be Valued Without Financial Statements?

Valuation may still be possible using other sources of information. However, the absence of financial statements makes it more difficult to verify the company’s financial position and performance. It may therefore require a broader accounting review or alternative supporting documents.

Do Overdue Debts Affect the Value of a Share?

Yes. Overdue debts may affect the value of collectible assets, while outstanding liabilities affect the company’s net value. The impact depends on the nature of the debt and the likelihood of collecting or settling it.

Is a Trademark Included in the Company’s Valuation?

A trademark may be included as an intangible asset if it is owned by the company or if the company holds legally provable and valuatable rights to it. Registration, ownership, and licensing documents should be reviewed before its value is included.

Who Is Responsible for Paying the Accredited Valuer’s Fees?

This depends on the relevant legal provisions, the agreement between the parties, the Articles of Association, and the circumstances of the case. Therefore, responsibility for valuation fees should be determined before beginning the exit process rather than assuming that a particular party is always responsible.

Can a Partner Object to the Valuation Report?

A partner may review the report and request clarification of the data and assumptions on which it is based. They may also appoint an independent expert to assess its accuracy. The procedure for handling an objection and its effect on any dispute depend on the applicable agreement, law, and procedures.

Does the Valuation Date Affect the Value of the Share?

Yes. Changes in assets, liabilities, profits, or significant events may cause the company’s value to differ from one date to another. Therefore, the valuation date must be clearly specified, taking into account the legal rule applicable to the type of exit.

Is an Internal Accountant’s Report Sufficient to Determine Fair Value?

An internal accountant’s report may be useful for preparing data and analyzing accounts. However, it does not replace a report prepared by an accredited valuer when required by law. Professional valuation may also require specialized expertise depending on the nature of the assets and business activity.

Conclusion

Valuing a partner’s share upon exit requires more than knowing the ownership percentage or reviewing the capital balance. It is a process that depends on a comprehensive examination of financial, accounting, legal, and commercial documents to establish a realistic picture of the company’s value, the partner’s rights, and the company’s obligations.

The more complete, up-to-date, and verifiable the documents are, the clearer the valuation process becomes, reducing the likelihood of disputes over the financial settlement or the discovery of unexpected liabilities after the exit.

Suleiman Al-Omari Law Firm – Lawyers and Legal and Sharia Consultants

The firm provides services in reviewing Articles of Association and partners’ agreements, offering legal consultations related to share valuation, partner exits and share transfers, drafting agreements to settle partners’ rights, and handling commercial disputes. These services help business owners make informed decisions and protect their rights and commercial interests.

📞 Contact: +966537778130

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute a substitute for specialized legal advice.